Ayumu Yokoyama has become something of a divisive figure among Birmingham City supporters, with the argument over his role at St Andrew's raging particularly hard after he wasn't called upon during Sunday's 0-0 draw with Blackpool. The natural fit for injured Emil Hansson, Yokoyama remained on the bench as Chris Davies instead turned to Luke Harris. It's a call that has continued the debate on the young Japanese winger's future and whether the key to unlocking his potential lies away from St Andrew's on loan.
Yokoyama's Limited Opportunities
Notably, Yokoyama is not getting playing time in League One. The 21-year-old has played just 134 minutes in the league - without starting a single game - since his cameo against Shrewsbury Town on November 23. He has featured prominently in cup competitions, starting all four matches in the Vertu Trophy and playing his part in the FA Cup win over Blackpool, but these have not translated into regular league chances.
The situation raises questions about his development. Without regular minutes in competitive matches, Yokoyama is unlikely to refine his skills or adapt fully to the physical demands of English football.
Chris Davies' Concerns
It's not out of the question that Yokoyama isn't playing because of tactical reasons. During a game against Northampton, he didn't track his runner, which saw an obvious outburst from Davies. That moment of indiscipline might still be remembered by the manager and stand between him and a place in the starting XI.
These, though, are the learning curves young players have to experience, and taking away these chances may hurt more than it helps. Injuries have mounted in Birmingham City's wide department, and it would not be long before Yokoyama is the sole natural winger option ahead of the New Year's Day trip to Stockport County, yet even then, it seems unlikely Davies will throw his trust in him to make the starting XI.
The Case for a Loan Move
For a 21-year-old who has already played significant football in Japan, the need for competitive minutes cannot be overstated. A loan move to a mid-table League One side could provide Yokoyama with the chance to play regularly without the intense pressure of promotion or relegation battles.
Such a move would allow him to:
- Valuable Experience: The regular game time in League One would get Yokoyama accustomed to the pace and physicality of the English game.
- Confidence Builder: Playing in a less pressurized environment could restore his confidence and show his full potential.
- Improve Tactical Awareness: Working under another manager might help Yokoyama address the tactical issues that have kept him sidelined at Birmingham City.
While there could be challenges, such as a potential language barrier, these are surmountable. Other clubs would likely be interested in Yokoyama's services, given his skill set and potential.
What's at Stake for Birmingham City?
Keeping Yokoyama without playing him would hinder his growth, which ultimately affects Birmingham City due to a wasted talent. Conversely, should he be in form and do well in his loan spell, then he might come back next season a more rounded player ready for service.
Conclusion
If Chris Davies continues to overlook Ayumu Yokoyama, then a loan transfer is something that really should be considered and sanctioned by Birmingham City. Allowing the young winger to get experience elsewhere could benefit both the player and the club in the long term. With injuries and inconsistencies in the squad, Yokoyama's development should not be an afterthought; it should be a priority.
Let Yokoyama prove himself elsewhere and come back much stronger, confident, and with all the artillery to shine in Birmingham City's colors.
